The problem is that clearml.conf s3 config doesnt support empty region field, even empty strings crashes it

I know these keys work, url and everything else works because I use these creds daily

we use Ceph Storage Cluster, interface to it is the same as S3
I dont get what I have misconfigured.
The only thing I have not added is "region" field in clearml.conf because we literally dont have, its a self hosted cluster.
You can try and replicate this s3 config I have posted earlier.

2024-02-08 11:23:52,150 - clearml.storage - ERROR - Failed creating storage object

Reason: Missing key and secret for S3 storage access (

)

(edited)

This looks unrelated, to the hotfix, it looks like you misconfigured something and therefor failing to write to s3

This is an actual AWS S3 bucket?

Bump, still waiting, closing in on a month since we are unable to deploy. We have team of 10+ people

Hey, i see that 1.14.2 dropped
I tried it but the issue is still there, maybe the hotfix is in next patch?

Here is the setup so you can reproduce it (we dont have region field)
clearml.conf:
s3 {
use_credentials_chain: false
credentials: [
{
host: " s3.somehost.com "
key: "XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX"
secret: "XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX"
bucket: "rnd-dev"
},
]
}

test.py

task: clearml.Task = clearml.Task.init(
project_name="project",
task_name="task",
output_uri=" None ",
)

2024-02-08 11:23:52,150 - clearml.storage - ERROR - Failed creating storage object None Reason: Missing key and secret for S3 storage access ( None )

Hi @<1590514584836378624:profile|AmiableSeaturtle81> , the hotfix should right around the corner 🙂

@<1523701070390366208:profile|CostlyOstrich36> Hello John, we are still unable to use clearml with our self hosted s3 CEPH instances, is there any update on the hotfix for 1.14?

@<1523701070390366208:profile|CostlyOstrich36> Any news on this? We are currently stuck without this fix, cant finish up clearml setup

I dont have a region. I guess I will wait till tomarrow then?

I think that the problem is with missing region definition. You need to set region in the config file.

But it looks like that for the existing version it will not work since there still appears to be a bug related to this. The hotfix is already on the way from my understanding

So, in short, you need to set the region in the config file + wait for the hotfix that is pending for 1.14

@<1523701070390366208:profile|CostlyOstrich36> Still unable to understand what im doing wrong.
We have self hosted S3 Ceph storage server
Setting my config like this breaks task.init

it looks like problem is the host field, whenever I add it I get:
2024-01-22 13:27:16,489 - clearml.storage - ERROR - Failed creating storage object None Reason: Missing key and secret for S3 storage access ( None )

Specifying it like this, gets me different error:

Exception has occurred: ValueError

• Insufficient permissions (delete failed) for None
  botocore.exceptions.ClientError: An error occurred (IllegalLocationConstraintException) when calling the DeleteObject operation: The me-south-1 location constraint is incompatible for the region specific endpoint this request was sent to.

During handling of the above exception, another exception occurred:

File "/home/ma/src/clearml-server/task_test.py", line 10, in <module>
task: clearml.Task = clearml.Task.init(
ValueError: Insufficient permissions (delete failed) for None

I cant get the conf credentials to work
Specifying it like this gives me:
Exception has occurred: ValueError
Could not get access credentials for ' None ' , check configuration file ~/clearml.conf

also, when uploading artifacts, I see where they are stored on the s3 bucket, but I cant find where the debug images are stored at

i need clearml.conf on my clearml server (in config folder which is mounted in docker-compose) or user PC? Or Both?
Its self hosted S3 thats all I know, i dont think it s Minio

Also, is it an AWS S3 or is it some similar storage solution like Minio?

Hi @<1590514584836378624:profile|AmiableSeaturtle81> , you need to setup your s3 key/secret in clearml.conf
I suggest following this documentation - None