normally when new package need to be install, it shows up in the Console tab
im not running in docker mode though
hmmm that might be the first issue. it cannot skip venv creation, it can however use a pre-existing venv (but it will change it every time it installs a missing package)
so setting CLEARML_AGENT_SKIP_PYTHON_ENV_INSTALL=1 in non docker mode has no affect
- try with the latest RC
1.8.1rc2
, it feels like after git clone, it spend minutes without outputting anything
yeah that is odd , can you run the agent with --debug (add before the daemon
command) , and then at the end of the command add --foreground
Now launch the same task on that queue, you will have a verbose log in the console.
Let us know what you see
would those containers best be started from something in services mode?
Yes as long as the machine has enough cpu/ram
Notice that the services mode will start a second parallel Task after the first one is done setting up the env, if running with CLEARML_AGENT_SKIP_PYTHON_ENV_INSTALL, with containers that have git/python/clearml-agent preinstalled it should be minimal.
or is it possible to get no-overhead with my approach of worker-inside-docker?
No do not do that, see above explanation on why CLEARML_AGENT_SKIP_PYTHON_ENV_INSTALL does not work in docker venv mode
i designed my tasks as different functions, based mostly on what metrics to report and artifacts that are best cached (and how to best leverage comparisons of tasks). they do require cpu, but not a ton.
just report a single Task as multiple "titles" then each title is it's own step, then inside the "title" they have different seriese
is there a way for me to toggle CLEARML's log level?
Try to set the python master logger base logging level
I can see all the steps like git clone,
git clone has nothing to do with "env setup" this is brining the code, you cannot skip that one, that said, this is why the git itself is cached on the host machine, so it is fast
... There may be some odd package that need to be installed because one of our DS is experimenting ... But all that we can see what is happening.
even if everything is preinstalled, it Verifies the packages match, this might take a long time. It's just pip being pip (if you want the extreme try to do the same with conda, that one is even slower)
the output of that verification stage is no new packages are installed (otherwise good thing we checked 🙂 )
bottom line, if you want to skip the pip verification/installation pass CLEARML_AGENT_SKIP_PYTHON_ENV_INSTALL=1
btw: i'm checking regrading the GH issue
minute of silence between first two msgs and then two more mins until a flood of logs. Basically 3 mins total before this task (which does almost nothing - just using it for testing) starts.
oh it's there, before running task.
from task pick-up to "git clone" is now ~30s, much better.
though as far as I understand, the recommendation is still to not run workers-in-docker like this:
export CLEARML_AGENT_SKIP_PYTHON_ENV_INSTALL=1
export CLEARML_AGENT_SKIP_PIP_VENV_INSTALL=$(which python)
(and fwiw I have this in my entrypoint.sh
)
cat <<EOF > ~/clearml.conf
agent {
vcs_cache {
enabled: true
}
package_manager: {
type: pip,
system_site_packages: true,
}
}
EOF
sometimes I get "lucky" and see something more like what I expect... total experiment time < 1 min (and I have evidence of this happening. logs start-to-finish in sub-minute). But then other times the same task will take 5-10 minutes.
same worker, same queue, just one worker serving it... I am so utterly perplexed by the variation in how long things take. my clearml API server is running on a beefy 32 core machine and not much else is happening right now...
fwiw - i'm starting to wonder if there's a difference between me "resetting the task" vs cloning it.
@<1689446563463565312:profile|SmallTurkey79> could you attach the full log of the Task?
also I would recommend "export CLEARML_AGENT_SKIP_PYTHON_ENV_INSTALL=1" (not true
)
Usually binary env vars are 0/1
(I can see that the docs here: None
never mention it, I'll ask them to add that)
you should be able to see int the Console tab that show what is happening
hard to see with your croppout here an there ...
of what task? i'm running lots of them and benchmarking execution times. would you like to see a best case or worst case scenario? (ive kept some experiments for each).
and yeah, in those docs you just linked, "boolean" vars like CLEARML_AGENT_GIT_CLONE_VERBOSE
explicitly say true
so I ended up trying that pattern. but originally i did try 1. let me go back to that now. thank you.
overall I've seen some improvements in execution time using the suggestions in this thread (tysm!) - the preinstalled libs seem to be helping, though some things are still just unbearably slow (one of my larger pipelines took > 1 h to generate a DAG before even starting...).
of what task? i'm running lots of them and benchmarking
If you are skipping every installation it should be the same
because if you set CLEARML_AGENT_SKIP_PYTHON_ENV_INSTALL=1
it will not install Anything at all
This is why it's odd to me...
wdyt?
but pretty reliably some proportion of tasks still just take a much longer time. 1m - 10m is a variance i'd really like to understand.
what if the preexisting venv is just the system python? my base image is python:3.10.10 and i just pip install all requirements in that image. Does that not avoid venv still?
it will basically create a new venv inside the container forking the existing preinistalled stuff (i.e. the new venv already has everything the python system has preinstalled)
then it will call "pip install" on all the "installed packages of the Task.
Which should just check everything is there and install nothing
If you set " CLEARML_AGENT_SKIP_PYTHON_ENV_INSTALL=1" it will do checks and just use the existing system python environment as is.
, I can get 50 tasks to run in the same time it takes to run a single one? i cant imagine the apiserver being a noticeable bottleneck.
50 containers on a single machine would be fine if you have enough RAM/CPU, and yes they would run concurrently.
regrading the time itself, again the spinup time of a Task should be negligible.
Pipeline tasks are not meant to be "threads" they are meant as different functions you want to run on different machines,
This means that if your pipeline is just a set of simple functions that require no cpu/gpu or IO, I'm not sure pipeline steps is the right way to go
Does that make sense?
i would love some advice on that though - should I be using services mode + docker and some max # of instances to be spinning up multiple tasks instead?
my thinking was to avoid some of the docker overhead. but i did try this approach previously and found that the container limit wasn't exactly respected.
I think a proper screenshot of the full log with some information redacted is the way to go. Otherwise we are just guessing in the dark
I know that git clone and pip verify all installed is normal. But for some reason in Michael screenshot, I don't see those steps ...
i really dont see how this provides any additional context that the timestamps + crops dont but okay.
from the logs, it feels like after git clone, it spend minutes without outputting anything. @<1523701205467926528:profile|AgitatedDove14> Do you know what is the agent suppose to do after git clone ?
I guess a check that all packages is installed ? But then with CLEARML_AGENT_SKIP_PYTHON_ENV_INSTALL=1, what is the agent doing ??
im not running in docker mode though - im running a clearml worker in a docker container (and then multiplying the container)
i just ran a pipeline that took about 2h (more than half this time was just the DAG), with about a hundred tasks. i'm taking a look at them now to see what the logs show for runtimes.
are you on clearml agent 1.8.0?
(im noticing sometimes im just missing logs such as "Running task id.." entirely)
i was having a ton of git clone issues - disabled caching entirely... wonder if that may help too.
tysm for your help! will report back soon.
thank you!
i'll take that design into consideration.
re: CLEARML_AGENT_SKIP_PYTHON_ENV_INSTALL in "docker venv mode" im still not quite sure I understand correctly - since the agent is running in a container, as far as it is concerned it may as well be on bare-metal.
is it just that there's no way for that worker to avoid venv? (i.e. the only way to bypass venv is to use docker-mode?)
1.12.2 because some bug that make fastai lag 2x
1.8.1rc2 because it fix an annoying git clone bug
i just need to understand what I should be expecting. I thought from putting it into queue in UI to "running my code remotely" (esp with packages preloaded) should be fairly fast turnaround - certainly not three minutes... i'll have to change my whole pipeline design if this is the case)
Please refer to here None
The doc need to be a bit clearer: one require a path and not just true/false
ha! yup. that was it exactly. I posted about it too None lol